Saturday, July 28, 2012

A Minute For Munich.

Yesterday was the opening of the Olympic Summer Games in London, England.  It was also the 40th anniversary of the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes at the Munich Games in 1972.  Across the world, leaders, citizens and journalists plead with the IOC to honour those athletes with one minute of silence during the Opening Ceremonies. Sixty seconds.

The IOC - Dr. Jacques Rogge in particular - refused.  Sure, he held a moment of silence at the signing of the Olympic Truce in Olympic Village, but to honour the murdered athletes for all the world to acknowledge?  No.

Many question why?  In some cases, people agree that the photo that is circulating around Facebook right now of Dr. Rogge wearing a Palestine Olympic scarf may be the reason.  It has been suggested that Dr. Rogge was a supporter of Hitler, a known anti-Semite and clearly a Palestine-supporter.  (Palestine - that fictional country that actually has a team competing at London!)

Dr. Rogge says the Games are not the place to launch a political agenda.  In saying this, and by denying the Israeli athletes a mere minute, he has done just that.

But don't think this went unnoticed.  

Bob  Costas, covering the Games for NBC made his feelings known to his audience.

As the Israelis marched behind flag-bearer Shahar Zubari, Costas said the London Games marked the 40th anniversary of the Munich tragedy.

“There have been calls from a number of quarters for the IOC to acknowledge that, with a moment of silence at some point in tonight’s ceremony. The IOC denied that request, noting it had honored the victims on other occasions. And in fact, this week (IOC president) Jacques Rogge led a moment of silence before about 100 people in the Athletes’ Village,” Costas said. “Still, for many, tonight, with the world watching, is the true time and place to remember those who were lost, and how they died.”
Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/olympics-2012/nbc-bob-costas-chides-international-olympic-committee-failing-recognize-munich-tragedy-article-1.1123759#ixzz21yeYRUrM

CTV's Olympic Correspondent, Brian Williams, Was even more vocal, by not shying away from the truth of the deaths of the athletes.  Bob Costas made no mention even remotely close to their deaths being from murder.  As far as anyone knew, they may have just dropped dead of their own accord.

Brian Williams, however, said the following:

As Israel prepares to enter, my position is well known. It is one that I have taken at previous Olympics. It is wrong that the IOC refuses to have a minute's silence for Israeli athletes that were slaughtered in Munich."

Williams, of course, was referring to the murder of 11 Israeli athletes during the 1972 Olympics.
"It is a much bigger issue this year, as it's the 40th anniversary of Munich. Members of the Canadian government, yesterday, our Governor General, all calling for a moment's silence. Dr Rogge (Jacques Rogge, President of the IOC) says the ceremony is not the place to remember a tragic event, but, uh, it's tragic, however, it's one of the most significant and world changing events in Olympic history. It absolutely should have been done here. The IOC worries about politics. This event is political by its very nature."

His co-Correspondant, Lisa LaFlamme neither agreed, nor refuted her co-Correspondant. In fact, the following is unofficial transcript of the ceremony:

Lisa LaFlamme: The widow of one of the victims spoke out saying 'they came with dreams, they went home in coffins.' They want to be remembered here tonight.

Brian Williams: And remember - they died as Olympians.

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs applauded Brian and Lisa for their courage and passionate stand.  As do I.

And, as if to add insult to injury, the IOC, or the London Olympic Committee (I'm not clear which) held a tribute to those involved in preparing for the London Games who had lost a family member in the past year.

Below, is a list fatalities
Shot during the initial break-in
  • Moshe Weinberg (wrestling coach)
  • Yossef Romano (weightlifter)
Shot and killed by grenade in helicopter D-HAQO
D-HAQO was the eastern helicopter.
According to the order in which they were seated, from left to right:
  • Ze'ev Friedman (weightlifter)
  • David Berger (weightlifter)
  • Yakov Springer (weightlifting judge)
  • Eliezer Halfin (wrestler)
Shot in helicopter D-HAQU
D-HAQU was the western helicopter.
According to the order in which they were seated, from left to right:
  • Yossef Gutfreund (wrestling referee)
  • Kehat Shorr (shooting coach)
  • Mark Slavin (wrestler)
  • Andre Spitzer (fencing coach)
  • Amitzur Shapira (track coach)
HaMakom yenachem etchem betoch sh'ar aveilei tzion v'Yerushalayim

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Why do Bad Things Happen to Good People (or, stop blaming the victims)

This post has little to do with my kosher journey but it is important to discuss.

Everyone is taking about the shooting in Aurora, Colorado at the midnight showing of the new Batman movie. One of the biggest, maybe most controversial issues coming out of most posts is the laying of blame on victims of this tragedy.

Among the patrons and victims it's been said, were a nine-year-old, a six-year-old and a 3-month-old.

Why were they there!? Because of course, it's their fault.

Why do we blame the victims? Or in this case, the parents of the victims. Why does society feel that it is entitled to add to the grief of the parents whose children were killed at the theatre? I challenge any parent to day they have NEVER had a lapse of judgement. That they have NEVER wanted to do something fun and crazy with their children.

I remember my parents waking me up late at night during a snowstorm to go for a walk in the big fluffy flakes. Does that make them irresponsible. Doubtful and at 38, it's still a fond memory.

Recently we took our nine year old twin girls to the drive-in. One daughter fell asleep during the second movie - the new Spiderman movie. The other stayed up and watched the whole thing. It was 2am before we left. Does that make me an irresponsible parent? I would only have been called such if something tragic had happened.

So maybe we need to stop blaming the victims and their parents. Maybe we need to look into ourselves and ask ourselves why a tragedy like this happened.